Here’s why I’m voting SYRIZA

I’m in Greece, partly so I can vote in the upcoming Greek elections where the leftist euro-reform party SYRIZA is expected to win. SYRIZA would probably win without me, but I felt it was important to come and vote for this important event. From the tone of the media inside or outside Greece you get the impression that a SYRIZA victory represents some kind of Euro disaster. On the contrary, I feel a SYRIZA government in Greece (or another one like it in Spain or Italy, this is about policy not people) is a bold step towards the solution. I regard it with optimism, even jubilation. Let me tell you why.

Disclaimer: I’m close to some SYRIZA candidates, policy thinkers, or MPs so I may be biased.

First why am I voting in Greece? I don’t live there. It would make more sense for me to vote in the UK where I live and pay taxes, but I don’t get the privilege. I guess native Britons are afraid I might vote for someone worse than David Cameron. Our concept of EU citizenship is still half-baked compared to America so we vote for national elections in our country of origin. We’ll fix it, but until then we have EasyJet democracy. In any case, I don’t feel strongly about voting on Greek affairs. I feel it’s important to vote, via Greece since that’s where I have a vote, for changes in Europe.

At a basic level I feel a duty to avert a bad outcome and push for a good one. If you recall, two elections ago the extreme right scored well in parliamentary elections in Greece. A surprising result that showed rising intolerance, fear, and naive insularity in Greek society. I find it abhorrent. At the same time you saw the Front National in France and Britain’s UKIP, which I see as equally negative but better at hiding behind a veil of respectability, gaining ground. SYRIZA is the polar opposite of these parties. In a climate of extreme right-wing euroskepticism, I feel it’s imperative to vote for leftist euro reform in Greece, Spain, or elsewhere. So that’s a defensive reason to turn up and vote.

The other reason, and the main one, is I don’t want an EU president and finance minister elected only by Germans, running the EU in a way that only suits Germany. Ms Merkel is our de-facto EU president. It’s clearly not Mr Hollande or Mr Juncker. Mr Schäuble is Europe’s finance minister. Whether German citizens like it or not, these officers set policy for the Eurozone, not just for Germany. They run the Eurozone in a way that serves the interests of narrow or short-sighted mostly German capital while driving real economies especially in the south into depression. This is wrong, and we need to use the democratic process to change it. Because of institutional inertia we non-Germans can’t vote for the Eurozone’s de-facto president and finance minister. Eventually these will be elected EU-wide but now, urgently, we must force our German-elected EU leaders to change their policies.

The way to do this is for the governments of peripheral countries to confront Ms Merkel and Mr Schäuble with the failure of their policies. This is what SYRIZA intends to do. It’s not an anti-Europe or anti-Euro party but it has to say, realistically, that current EU policy towards the periphery is not working. Greece’s economy is in depression and it’s debt is unsustainable, as it has been since 2010. Debt restructuring and expansionary monetary policy are needed to end the crisis. A growing consensus of economists agree, so we witness establishment papers like the FT urging the same policies that SYRIZA favors, for pragmatic economic reasons.

What will happen if SYRIZA is elected and starts renegotiating debt and austerity measures with Berlin? I think mainly compromise. EU institutions will have to accept balance sheet losses, which can easily be covered by monetary expansion. Greece will have to live within its means day to day, which given the big drop in incomes since 2010 is now possible. SYRIZA is new so it can enact better tax policy, touching previously untouchable classes, and in return can reasonably ask the EU for welfare assistance towards the poorest citizens. On election night the markets will jitter and possibly overreact, but forcing a Grexit is in nobody’s interest. In the long run markets agree with SYRIZA’s program and EU-wide policies such as quantitative easing that it aligns with.

A win for SYRIZA will be an important event for Europe, not because Greece is important but because some peripheral country needs to stand up for a change in EU policy. It could be Spain or Ireland, but looks like it’ll be Greece. Far from that being a disaster or some new chapter in the Euro crisis, I think it’ll be a triumph of the democratic process and post-crisis Europe’s finest hour.

Είναι επικίνδυνος ή αναγκαίος ο ΣΥΡΙΖΑ?

An unusual blog post in Greek about the suitability or otherwise of the socialist SYRIZA party for governance. I think it’s what Greece needs. Translate this badly with Google.

Το παρακάτω ακολουθέι απο μια συζήτηση με τον πατέρα μου, που λέει περίπου τα παρακάτω (συνοπτικά):

Ο ΣΥΡΙΖΑ είναι επικίνδυνος γιατί διακατέχεται απο αριστερές επαναστατικές ή λαικίστικες ιδέες που δεν ταιριάζουν στην εποχή μας ή δεν είναι δυνατόν να τις εφαρμόσει η Ελλάδα όταν περιβαλλόμαστε απο μια άκρως καπιταλιστική Ευρώπη που απαραίτητα μας στηρίζει. Αν βγεί λοιπόν θα κάνει κινήσεις τύπου Αντρέα ή τίποτα ή χειρότερες τυχοδιωκτικές ζημιές.

Η απάντησή μου:

Οι δυο παραμετροι που προσδιορίζουν την κίνηση της Ελλάδας ειναι το πρωτογενές έλλειμα/πλεόνασμα, αν δηλαδή μπορούμε να ζήσουμε τον εαυτό μας, και οι προσδοκίες των Ελλήνων για το πώς θέλουν και φαντάζονται τη χώρα αυτή και το μέλλον.

Οσον αφορα το πρωτογενές έλλειμα:

Όλη τη σύγχρονη περίοδο το Ελληνικό κράτος δε μπορούσε να συλλέξει αρκετά χρήματα για τα έξοδα του και κάλυπτε το κενό με κάποιου είδους πληθωρισμό: Έκδοση χρημάτων, υποτίμηση της δραχμής, ή δανεισμό (έκδοση ομολόγων) χωρίς να υπάρχει πρόθεση ή προοπτική αυτο το “χρέος” να επιστραφεί ποτέ. Έτσι κάνει και η Αμερική. Τα ομόλογα των χωρών κατα κανόνα ανακυκλώνονται και αυξάνονται αενάως. Οι πρώτες δυο μέθοδοι έκλεισαν με το ευρώ, και τα ομόλογα δούλευαν μέχρι το 2008 οπότε τα χτύπησαν οι επενδυτές και τα επιτόκια εκτινάχτηκαν.

Continue reading